This started as part of a discussion on poor reading standards and testing of children in schools (which may be posted in the future). Somehow in my brain they are linked.
When I started this blog (2008) I’d joined Ravelry and had used some closed (not public) online forums, was on Friends Reunited and I followed some blogs. Facebook and Twitter were in their infancy (and I did not join them for some years). It had never dawned on me that my somewhat eclectic ramblings could one day be scooped up with the rest of everything that’s ever been published on the internet, and then used to train AI. (Is that ethical?)
I am fed up of seeing AI generated content – particularly on Facebook. I find myself reading long but uninteresting things that I belatedly realise are AI. There are weird videos that aim to be cute (for some reason babies and kittens seem to be a common topic) but are just creepy (and not in a good “Nightmare before Christmas” way).
On Facebook I find that if I “follow” a page, I suddenly no longer see it – but dupes of that page pop up regularly. Instagram is now a video platform (they’ve even abandoned their square format for photos and on profile pages – destroying carefully curated accounts) and I abandoned Twitter/X sometime ago. The wider internet is littered with unintelligent writing liberally scattered with adverts and pop-ups. There are “news” sites that will only allow you to view them if all cookies are accepted or you pay (and turn out to be AI generated sop when finally viewed in a private window). Cory Doctorow’s “Enshittification” describes things exactly.
I don’t like my work being stolen and I don’t want to be competing with AI sop. Now when I write something (or post photos) my work becomes fodder for training AIs. Is that a psychological barrier to writing (on top of being crazy busy all the time, so I have little time for documenting projects even when I’m creating)? I wonder if we should poison the well (if it hasn’t already been poisoned and corrupted by AI), then pick up our skirts and take our creative output elsewhere (to a bright new internet), so we can still share and learn and grow, but it can’t be used or tainted by AI*.
*I obviously don’t know how we would do this.