The current UK Education Secretary is so concerned about the reading standards of children, that she’s “ready to take on [teaching] unions” to push through compulsory reading tests in Year 8 (that’s children 12 and 13 years old, if you’re not familiar with the UK school system). What is the point of a test without changes (meaning targetted investment) that will improve reading for all children? I don’t see any proposals that will tackle the issue of access to books.
Hmmmm, yes, what?!
I really mean that, access to books. There are reading schemes in both the UK and the US that aim to get books into children’s hands. These are fab. They are there because access to books and reading are known to improve outcomes in education (and life). However, they are a nibble at the corner of what has become a much bigger problem.
But the UK’s a rich country, why are you blathering about access to books?
“Despite the UK being one of the richest countries in the world, around 4.5 million children (1 in 3) live in poverty. Children in lone-parent families face an even higher risk, with 4 in 10 living in poverty.” from Joseph Rowntree Foundation. So, although the UK is “rich”, many people have very limited budgets and book buying isn’t likely to be a priority.
Books are expensive. I’m not complaining – authors need to be paid. Here’s an example, a favourite book of my son when he was young was SuperCat (a fun story that really got him reading – it was a gift from a party he’d attended). It’s by Jeanne Willis and is currently £5.99 on Amazon. There are two more books in the series (£5.99 and £6.99) and then more books by Jeanne that may also appeal. But that first set of books is nearly £19 in total. Books for older children tend to be more expensive. For example, Phillip Pullman’s “His Dark Materials” tend to be around £8 for each book, and the three books as a set are around £20.
Second-hand may be an option, but children don’t always look after books particularly well (they may have taken a long time to read, or been lost under the bed for a while). This makes getting children’s books second-hand tricky. With luck they’ll turn up in a charity shop or second-hand bookshop (where condition can be checked), if not then online has to be used. World of books has the three SuperCat books at £3.50 each, making this a £10.50 purchase – so still quite expensive when we’re constantly considering the cost of food and heating the home. Again, cost of travel may be an issue to get to second-hand book shops or charity shops in towns. The best (and largest) second-hand bookshop I know is in the middle of the countryside (so only accessible with a car). Sadly, the e-reader (including the Kindle) although great for accessibility and immediate access to books, stops any re-selling of books and effectively removes a proportion of books from the second-hand market.
Another option is discount book sellers. We lost a really good one around the start of the pandemic, which was widely used by families (including mine). Other discount stores have also closed over the years as the model for printing books has changed and there are fewer remainder books to sell cheaply. There are still some discount stores online and The Works has both an online and high-street presence (though I feel they have fewer books available than they used to pre-pandemic). The Works currently have some children’s books available in sets around £10-£12 (but they do feel a little dated).
Reading isn’t just about books, though. All reading is valid and should include other sources. I’m thinking particularly about the comic strip children’s comics that used to be published but have now mostly disappeared. There are a selection of children’s magazines – often with a knowledge focus. These are great if they appeal to a child’s interest – but again can be expensive (for example, Aquila works out at about £6 an issue if bought a year in advance or on a rolling subscription).
An obvious option is libraries. However, after years of austerity (thank you, Tories) they are chronically underfunded. The ones that exist have restricted opening times, often staffed by one paid librarian and (hopefully) volunteers, and they have a small selection of books. If you’re lucky, then there is a library within walking distance of where you live. However, lots of libraries have been permanently closed in the UK, further limiting access. If you need to travel to get to a library (or a bigger library) then that will cost (car running costs, plus fuel and parking, or bus fares). I live in quite a large village and these are the opening times of our library (at least we have one):
Monday: Closed
Tuesday: 10am to 5pm
Wednesday: 4pm to 7pm
Thursday: 2pm to 5pm
Friday: 10am to 5pm
Saturday: 10am to 1pm
Sunday: Closed
Closed on Bank Holidays
Total hours open: 23 hours
So, what’s your solution? Do you have one or is this just a massive rant?
I’d argue that poor reading skills of children isn’t just about education, it’s a societal issue. We need affordable (or even better, free) access to books and other sources of reading material. Libraries need longer opening hours and a huge investment into the books and other materials available. If my village library was open 6 days a week from 10am until 7pm, then that would be 54 hours open each week (as opposed to its current 23 hours). Just think about that for a minute – we have public buildings that are closed more each week than they are open. A library only open 23 hours a week is acting more as gatekeeper to knowledge, than as a portal to knowledge.
We also need to ensure that everyone in villages, suburbs, towns and cities have access to libraries. This will mean opening libraries where they’ve closed or improving public transport AND making it affordable or even free!
Libraries being open longer has other benefits. They can provide warm spaces when people are struggling with the cost of living. For children they can provide a different study space if they struggle to have space to complete homework at home. Libraries can also provide access to computers and online services for everyone, including children completing homework.
But no one is going to come into the libraries!
Librarians are excellent at providing activities in libraries. Some libraries run art clubs after school and rhyme times and story times are common for very young children. My local library offers reading groups, knit and natter, a digital buddy assistant and a Duplo club. I’ve also seen coding clubs being offered and jigsaws being available for adults to complete in the library. All of these are free activities that encourage engagement with and use of the library space.
And schools?
Children spend a lot of time in school, so extra funding is needed for books in the school library system and time explicitly given in the school week for children to visit their school’s library to borrow books. While most secondary schools do retain a library, infant and junior schools have limited libraries with restrained times that children can access them. The Great School Libraries “Equal Futures” report shows a lack of ring-fenced funding for libraries, falling budgets and decreasing stock levels within school libraries. School funding is widely reported to be stretched to the limit, so funding should be new and not somehow extracted from the already inadequate school budget.
So, my challenge to Bridget Phillipson and the current government, is to stop talking about more compulsory testing, which will not improve reading. Instead they should be working to reverse the effects of years of Tory austerity and to actively invest in reading.







